13 sources cited

Dumper's regret stages: is there any evidence?

Short answer

No study has found fixed stages or a timeline of regret in people who end relationships, and the stage models online contradict each other. Research does show that mixed feelings about leaving are common and that some couples reunite, but you cannot read that off a calendar. Waiting for her regret keeps you stuck. Work on your own week instead.

Key takeaways

  • No study has found a fixed sequence of stages or a regret timeline in people who end relationships.
  • The stage lists copy the five stages of grief, which have poor evidence behind them even for bereavement.
  • Research on people who leave shows mixed feelings and real costs, not a schedule.
  • Reunions are common among young adults, but on-off relationships report lower quality on average.
  • Preoccupation with an ex is linked to poorer adjustment, so build your own week instead of tracking hers.
A woman seen from behind at a window at dusk, holding a cup.

The claim: 5, 6 or 10 stages of dumper's remorse

The claim is that everyone who ends a relationship moves through a fixed sequence: relief, then doubt, then nostalgia, then regret, often with dates attached. No study has found that sequence. The lists do not even agree with each other on how many stages there are, what they are called or how long each one lasts.

Search the phrase and the count changes from page to page: five stages here, six or seven there, ten somewhere else. Some pages put regret inside the first month. Others say it can take far longer. If these were measurements of the same thing, they would roughly match. They read like what they are: stories written for people who are hurting and want a date to hold on to.

That wish makes sense. A timeline turns waiting into something that feels like a plan. But an invented timeline costs you real weeks, and this guide will not hand you a new one.

Where the stage models come from

As far as we can find, they come from coaches' impressions, reader comments and forum threads, arranged in the shape of the five stages of grief. We found none that cites a study following people after they ended a relationship.

The grief stages are a weak template to copy. Kübler-Ross described denial, anger, bargaining, depression and acceptance in 1969, based on her conversations with dying patients. She and many others then applied the stages to people who had lost someone. A 2017 review by Stroebe, Schut and Boerner concluded that the stages were never derived from systematic study of the bereaved, that they lack empirical support, and that professionals should stop using them to guide people [1].

The review also describes what happened when researchers tracked real grief over time. In one study that followed older couples from before a death to after it, only 11 percent of the bereaved took the path traditionally assumed to be normal, high distress that fades with time, while 46 percent reported stable, low distress throughout [1].

So the dumper's remorse model is an untested copy of a model that did not hold up in its own field. Stages are attractive because they promise order. Real people after real breakups are not that tidy.

What research actually shows about the person who leaves

Research on people who end relationships shows mixed feelings, real costs and a wide range of outcomes. It does not show a sequence.

Mixed feelings before the decision are common

Joel, MacDonald and Page-Gould asked people who were weighing a breakup or divorce about their reasons to stay and their reasons to leave. Many were motivated to stay and to leave at the same time, and the authors concluded that ambivalence is a common experience for people thinking about ending a relationship [2]. So second thoughts are real. In this research they show up before the breakup, not on a schedule after it.

Leaving hurts less than being left, but it still hurts

In a survey of 5,705 people in 96 countries, those who were left reported more grief than those who did the leaving, and the authors describe the grief as still relatively severe for both [3]. Perilloux and Buss, studying 193 people, found that those who were left reported more depression, loss of self-esteem and rumination. Those who ended it faced a different cost: being seen by others as cruel [4].

In one small study, the people who left were not ambushed

Eastwick and colleagues followed 69 college freshmen in relationships and analyzed the 26 who broke up, comparing how upset each had predicted they would be with how upset they were over the next ten weeks. The 14 who ended the relationship themselves showed no significant gap between forecast and reality. The 5 who were left and the 7 whose breakup was mutual had expected to feel worse than they did [5].

That cuts against the core of the stage story, which says the dumper sails through relief and then gets hit by pain she never saw coming. In this sample, the ones who left felt roughly what they had expected to feel and left anyway. The limits are plain: 14 students and ten weeks [5]. The study cannot rule out a change of heart at month six. It gives you no reason to expect one either.

Relief is real, and nobody has timed it

Sbarra and Emery had 58 young adults complete an emotions diary for 28 days after a breakup. Relief was one of the emotions they tracked, alongside love, sadness and anger, and it moved in a curve instead of a straight line [6]. The study was not built to time a "relief stage" in the person who ended things, and we found no other study that has done it.

Claim, evidence, verdict: the dumper regret myths checked

Most of the popular claims have nothing under them, and the two with some support do not say what the stage lists need them to say.

Claim What the evidence says Verdict
Every dumper goes through the same stages No study has found a stage sequence. The grief stages these lists copy lack support themselves [1] No evidence
Regret arrives at a set time (3 weeks, 30 days, 2 to 6 months) No study has timed regret after a breakup No evidence
The dumper feels only relief at first Relief is real, but people who leave also report grief, and many had mixed feelings going in [2] [3] Mixed
The dumper gets hit by unexpected pain later In one small study, the 14 people who ended it felt about what they had predicted over the next ten weeks [5] No evidence
No contact triggers her regret No study has tested it No evidence
Dumpers often come back Reunions are common among young adults, but the studies do not show who came back or why [7] [8] Mixed
Women regret breakups more than men Women were more likely than men to name a regret about love over one about work. No study measures regret over a specific breakup [9] No evidence

Is there a female dumper regret timeline?

No. There is no timeline for women, for men or for anyone. No study has measured when a woman who ended a relationship starts to regret it, or whether she does.

Two findings get stretched to fill the gap.

The first is about who ends relationships. A US study followed 2,262 adults with opposite-sex partners from 2009 to 2015 and recorded 371 breakups, 92 of them marriages. Women wanted about 69 percent of the marital breakups, while among unmarried couples men and women were about equally likely to be the one who wanted out [10]. That describes who tends to end marriages. It says nothing about regret.

The second is about regret in general. In a US telephone survey of 370 adults, each person described one life regret. Regrets about romance were more common than regrets in any other area of life, and women were more likely than men to name a regret about love over one about work [9]. The survey covered regrets about love of any kind. It did not ask whether anyone regretted ending a particular relationship, and it cannot tell you what one woman feels about you.

So "do women regret breaking up?" has one honest answer. Some do, some do not, and nobody has counted.

Do dumpers come back?

Sometimes. Reunions are common enough that researchers study them. But the studies count couples who got back together. They do not show that the person who left came back, when, or because of regret.

What the research says

Halpern-Meekin, Manning, Giordano and Longmore (2013) analyzed 792 unmarried daters and cohabitors aged 17 to 24 from the Toledo Adolescent Relationships Study [7]. In their current or most recent relationship, 44.8 percent reported a breakup followed by a reunion. Limits: young unmarried adults from one county in Ohio, one partner's report, and a single point in time. The paper reports how often couples reunited, not who regretted what or when. Verdict: Supported that reunions are common in young adults. No evidence for a regret timeline.

Other samples point the same way. Among 445 US college students, almost two-thirds had been in an on-again, off-again relationship at some point [8]. In a national US sample of 323 cohabiting and 752 married couples, over one-third of cohabiters and one-fifth of spouses had broken up and renewed during their current relationship [11].

Getting back together is not the same as it working. In the college research, people in on-off relationships reported fewer positives, such as love and understanding from their partner, and more negatives, such as communication problems and uncertainty. More renewals went with worse reports [8]. Among cohabiting and married couples, those who had cycled reported lower satisfaction and more uncertainty about the future [11]. These studies cannot say why. One fair reading is that a reunion where nothing has changed brings the old problems back with it.

For the full picture, read how often exes come back and the signs your ex will come back, checked against the evidence.

Why waiting for her regret keeps you stuck

Waiting puts your recovery on a clock that does not exist. Every day spent watching for stage three is a day you did not train, sleep properly or see your friends.

The research on that kind of waiting points one way. In a study of 231 young adults after a breakup, preoccupation with the ended relationship and romantic regret both went with poorer adjustment [12]. In a survey of 464 people, monitoring an ex's Facebook page went with more distress, more longing and less personal growth [13]. Both studies are snapshots, so they cannot prove cause. But stage-watching combines the two habits they flag: brooding over her, and checking for clues.

Waiting on her timeline Running yours
You count days since the breakup You count training sessions this week
You check her profile for signs of a stage Her feed is muted
Your mood depends on what she posts Your mood depends on what you did today
If she never reaches out, the months are lost If she never reaches out, you are still fitter, sharper and steadier

There is a practical side too. If she does get in touch, she meets the man you are on that day. Three months of decoding her posts leaves you the same man with worse sleep. Three months of work leaves you someone different, whether she calls or not.

Her regret, or the lack of it, also changes nothing about what you are allowed to do. If she asked for no contact, blocked you, or there is a legal order, respect it completely. Do not test the boundary because a stage list says she should be missing you by now. And if she left because she felt afraid or controlled, there is no timeline to discuss. Her safety comes first. Leave her alone, and get qualified support for yourself, starting with a doctor.

The guide on whether the no contact rule works explains what silence is for, and what she is thinking during no contact explains why you cannot read her mind from it. If the loop in your head is the bigger problem, start with how to stop thinking about your ex. The rest of the get her back guides follow the same rule: evidence first, and no invented timelines.

If the waiting has turned into weeks of barely sleeping or eating, or you are having thoughts of harming yourself, see a doctor or call a local crisis line today.

Do this today

Delete the countdown and replace it with a week. It takes 15 minutes.

  1. Delete any note, app or calendar entry that counts days since the breakup or days until a "stage".
  2. Open your calendar for the next seven days. Enter three training sessions, one fixed wake-up time and one plan with a friend, in person.
  3. Mute her feed so there is nothing to check for signs.

The free plan works on the same pieces: Go quiet (mute her, archive the chat, a friend on call) and Find your max in week one, then Sleep like it counts, with one wake time every day, in week two. It runs four weeks, one move at a time, and needs no account. Stop waiting on her timeline: start yours.

Questions men ask

When do dumpers start to regret?

There is no known time. No study has measured when regret starts after someone ends a relationship, or how often it happens at all. The timelines online (three weeks, 30 days, two to six months) contradict each other because none of them comes from data. Regret may come quickly, slowly or never, and you cannot read which applies to her from a calendar.

Does the dumper miss the dumpee?

She may. In a survey of 5,705 people in 96 countries, people who ended a relationship reported less grief than people who were left, but the authors describe the grief as still relatively severe on both sides. Grief is not the same as wanting you back, though. A person can miss a partner and still be certain the relationship was wrong for them.

How long does dumper's relief last?

Nobody has measured it. A 28-day diary study of 58 young adults tracked relief after breakups and found it changed in a curve instead of a straight line, with the same people reporting sadness and anger alongside it. The study was not designed to time relief in the person who ended things. Any site that gives you a number of weeks is inventing it.

Do women regret breaking up?

Some do and some do not, and no study has counted. The nearest data is general: in a US telephone survey of 370 adults, romance was the most common area of life regret, and women were more likely than men to name a regret about love over one about work. That survey covered regrets about love of any kind, not regret over ending a particular relationship. It cannot tell you what your ex feels.

Sources

Every source below was opened during drafting and review. The note under each one says who was studied and what it cannot show.

  1. Stroebe, Schut, Boerner (2017). Cautioning health-care professionals: Bereaved persons are misguided through the stages of grief. OMEGA: Journal of Death and Dying, 74(4), 455-473.

    A review and commentary on stage theories of grief, with no new data; it concerns bereavement, so applying it to breakup stage lists is our comparison.

  2. Joel, MacDonald, Page-Gould (2018). Wanting to stay and wanting to go: Unpacking the content and structure of relationship stay/leave decision processes. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 9(6), 631-644.

    Three samples listed reasons to stay or leave, and a further sample of people contemplating a breakup or divorce rated them (the abstract gives no sample sizes); self-reports gathered before any breakup, so it says nothing about regret afterward.

  3. Morris, Reiber, Roman (2015). Quantitative sex differences in response to the dissolution of a romantic relationship. Evolutionary Behavioral Sciences, 9(4), 270-282.

    Survey of 5,705 people in 96 countries, about three-quarters of whom had been through a breakup and rated it; grief reported from memory, with no measure of regret.

  4. Perilloux, Buss (2008). Breaking up romantic relationships: Costs experienced and coping strategies deployed. Evolutionary Psychology, 6(1), 164-181.

    193 participants reporting on a breakup as the one who left or the one who was left; a single self-report sample that did not track anyone over time.

  5. Eastwick, Finkel, Krishnamurti, Loewenstein (2008). Mispredicting distress following romantic breakup: Revealing the time course of the affective forecasting error. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 44(3), 800-807.

    69 Northwestern University freshmen were followed for nine months and the 26 who broke up were analyzed (14 ended it themselves, 7 called it mutual, 5 were left); a very small sample of 17 to 19 year olds, with distress tracked for only ten weeks.

  6. Sbarra, Emery (2005). The emotional sequelae of nonmarital relationship dissolution: Analysis of change and intraindividual variability over time. Personal Relationships, 12(2), 213-232.

    58 young adults completed an emotions diary for 28 days after a serious dating relationship ended; a small, unmarried sample, not designed to time emotions in the person who ended it.

  7. Halpern-Meekin, Manning, Giordano, Longmore (2013). Relationship Churning in Emerging Adulthood: On/Off Relationships and Sex With an Ex. Journal of Adolescent Research, 28(2), 166-188.

    792 unmarried daters and cohabitors aged 17 to 24 from the Toledo Adolescent Relationships Study in one Ohio county; cross-sectional, one partner's report, and no data on regret or timing.

  8. Dailey, Pfiester, Jin, Beck, Clark (2009). On-again/off-again dating relationships: How are they different from other dating relationships? Personal Relationships, 16(1), 23-47.

    445 US college students in the first study and a further 236 participants in the second; self-reports about their own dating relationships, so the findings may not hold for older adults or marriages.

  9. Morrison, Roese (2011). Regrets of the typical American: Findings from a nationally representative sample. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 2(6), 576-583.

    Random-digit telephone survey of 370 US adults who each described one regret (sample size from the Kellogg School of Management summary, since the abstract gives none); regrets about love in general, not regret over ending a relationship.

  10. Rosenfeld (2018). Who wants the breakup? Gender and breakup in heterosexual couples. In Alwin, Felmlee and Kreager (Eds.), Social Networks and the Life Course (pp. 221-243). Springer.

    2,262 US adults with opposite-sex partners followed from 2009 to 2015, with 371 breakups of which 92 were marital (counts checked in the author's 2015 conference draft); it records who wanted the breakup, not regret.

  11. Vennum, Lindstrom, Monk, Adams (2014). "It's complicated": The continuity and correlates of cycling in cohabiting and marital relationships. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 31(3), 410-430.

    A weighted national US sample of 323 cohabiting and 752 married couples; breakups and renewals were recalled from memory, and only couples currently together were included.

  12. Saffrey, Ehrenberg (2007). When thinking hurts: Attachment, rumination, and postrelationship adjustment. Personal Relationships, 14(3), 351-368.

    231 young adults whose relationship of at least three months had ended in the past year; a one-time survey that cannot show rumination causes poor adjustment.

  13. Marshall (2012). Facebook Surveillance of Former Romantic Partners: Associations with PostBreakup Recovery and Personal Growth. Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking, 15(10), 521-526.

    464 people recruited online (84 percent women, mean age 21) in a single survey; correlational, so it cannot show whether checking causes distress or distressed people check more.